Scoring finished:
226 days ago
Submitted on:
Jan 10 '08
Scored by:
1,886 people
Comments:
51 comments
Final average score:
2.59 out of 5
 |
|
|
|
|
|
 |
Hah, I actualy like this one alot. I like how you put it on a green shirt. 5$
|
 |
very cute
|
 |
Cute!!
|
 |
DAMN THAT'S GOOD! A surefire hit for the kiddies. Nice work.
|
 |
ah ahaha this is great! loves it $5
|
 |
WOWEE. That is the most original design I have seen on this site. I love this shirt. livincompany.com
|
 |
that's great
|
 |
haha i love the smiles on the stumps faces hahah
|
|
this is the most amazing shirt there has every been.
i wish i was this shirt, so i could love myself. |
 |
Thanks guys! Especially to Murraymullet, I'd never heard of livincompany before but I really enjoyed their stuff when looking through it just now. Thanks for the link! ;)
|
|
very cute- but i don't know if i would have know they were stumps if i hadn't just read it.
|
 |
too cute...
|
|
in a good way that is... that above comment sounded a little odd... I like it!
|
 |
They are quite clearly stumps. $$$$$
|
 |
wotto on Jan 10 '08 lol
|
 |
Bisparulz on Jan 10 '08 nice 5$
|
 |
stumps make it work!!!
I love this one I hope it wins so I can buy one :D |
 |
Cute. I'd buy it for my niece and nephew.
|
 |
hey. $5
you know me a bit |
|
^ah yeah! hello and thanks luke!
|
 |
Adorable!
|
 |
Dark on dark is kind of bleak and makes it difficult to capture the concept quickly. Maybe add the same texture on the stacked stumps to the trunks of the trees to solidify the "stump" connection because I seriously didn't get it until reading your description. Make the cutting plane that is the top of each stump a much lighter color...just like real trees. Swirl is perfect. Let a thin ledge of that lighter wood color show on a few of the other stumps in the stack to enrich that jostled, funstack visual. Put a crow in one of the trees; he can be the embittered rival or small-percentage-talent entity.
|
|
And you have two colors of stumps. Put the darker color trunk on at least one of the trees.
|
|
Thanks a lot for the thought out critique but some of what you mentioned I had already considered and tried and it did not look as well as this finished design. I'm honestly surprised that a couple people couldn't recognize that the characters were stumps of wood, but I suppose that just surprises me because I have been using this simple shape for a few years now to get that image across and no one has voiced that opinion till now.
As for the tiny crow, I actually think that's a really neat idea but I would be concerned about what adding an extra element, especially an extra "live" character would mean to the design. I think it would become too much of a focus and I like to keep things simpler. Does anyone else think that there is not enough contrast between the purple and green? I know they are both somewhat darker shades but I believed that their contrasting colours were enough. |
 |
WANNAHAVE
|
 |
THIS IS GREAT!!!
|
 |
i didn't get that they were stumps at first, but it is still cute
|
|
^oh man :(, were the shapes reminiscent of anything else at first or do the people who didn't see stumps just not have any inkling as to what they could be?
|
 |
hahaha, cuuuute! I love it
|
|
Yesss, this is super cute.
X.Oh.x., Acadia |
|
I love the trees faces.
|
 |
this is so adorable! good job, ginette!
|
|
heheh i like your design $5
|
 |
put a smile on my face $5
|
 |
the grins on the stump's faces sell this beyond the call of duty. 4$
|
|
they are clearly stumps, i think some people spend too much time in the city....thats what trees look like once you chop them. true story.
|
|
people are obviously just over analyzing . $5
|
|
yay
i see them as stumps just fine |
 |
i feel like this shirt deserves a hug! $5 ftw!
|
|
and a couple of the stumps are waving with their stump-like arms also... hehehe
|
 |
Lmfao.
|
 |
The Paper Crane on Jan 14 '08 I like it - random!
|
 |
h aha !! 5
|
|
What stumps are you all talking about?
|
|
Stumps of wood obviously.
|
 |
ilovedoodle on Jan 14 '08 this make me laugh :)
|
 |
just cute... that's all. i wish there's something more!
|
|
I would be very, very surprised if this doesn't get printed. It's so freakin cute. Very well done. Congrats on the money and the honor. 5$
|
|
actually JoeMonster there is something more to it. this was one of the concepts i cooked up for a project on overcoming adversity, so just because i did it in a cutesy way doesn't mean it's a shallow illustration.
|
|
geez louise, thanks for the congrats eyedewtwo but i doubt very much i'll win with this one as much as i do like it.
but i'm crossing my fingers :S |
|
You totally deserved that score.
|
11 days later
 |
funny.. i like your comment on my sub, even though it was negative. u have a good sense of humour :)
|
4 days later
 |
cute :) and a really nice score!
|
7 days later
 |
Completely generic. Are you designing for 5th Graders?
|
|
I agree with joncainecu "Completely generic".
|
|
Ouch, thanks for trying to attack my designs because you disagree with my critical comments!
|
5 days later
 |
P
R i N T ! ! ! ! ! ! |
6 days later
|
trees?? lame
|
39 days later
|
Lovely!
|
3 days later
|
I don't know why this and Ghost Stumps weren't printed.
|
 |
I'm stumping for YOU!
|
8 days later
 |
yeah this is awesome. It's pretty rare that I would actually wear any shirt off threadless, even my own, but this I would.
|
13 days later
 |
This should've been printed, especially because of those SMILES.
|
8 days later
 |
HAHAH cute!
http://www.threadless.com/critique/20074/INSIDE |
4 days later
 |
I'll give you points for re-drawing each stump and tree, a feat most artists here fail to accomplish anymore.
|
|
of course they're redrawn, copy-pasting is for dopes!
|
8 days later
 |
It's great!
|
 |
i love it soooobaaaaad!!!
|
21 days later
 |
p
r i n t p l e a s e ! |
 |
m
e t o o ! |
You must be logged in to leave a comment.
Update: Aug 29, '08
|
 |
Update: Ken Marshall
|
|
Threadspotting every Friday!
|
|
You know they'll love it!
|
Catalog ·
Stock Chart ·
Select ·
Type Tees ·
12 Club ·
Kids!
|
Score Designs ·
Submit Ideas ·
Photos ·
Loves ·
Street Team ·
Forum
|
News ·
Help ·
Order Status ·
Contact ·
Press
|
© 2008, a skinnyCorp LLC company.
All designs Copyright by owner.
Privacy Policy.
Terms of Use.
Weekly new tees
In stock
News
Submissions
Thriftee
Weekly new tees
In stock
News
Submissions
Thriftee
stump power!